Eparchy of Saint Maron of Brooklyn

 Intro

The past few years I have approached prayer with some fear and trembling.  I ask myself whether my humble prayer is acceptable to God.   At times I feel great consolation and peace, and at other times I feel far from God and I long for a closer union. Sometimes I feel I am really praying and at other times it seems that I am just passing time or reciting words.

The Directory for the Life and Ministry of Bishops, published by the Apostolic See, gives a sobering reminder of the importance of prayer in the life of the Bishop: 

“The Bishop should consider his responsibility for divine worship to be his pre-eminent role...” (Par.142) He should diligently seek to cultivate in himself and in the faithful a religious disposition towards God…In celebrating the sacred mysteries, he should be absorbed by the mystery unfolding before him….He should be mindful that the celebrations at which he presides are to set an example for all other celebrations.”  (Par.144)

I question if my prayer during liturgy is authentic. The Maronite Evening Prayer for Tuesday in Lent reminds me: 

“There is a distinction between fast and true fast, prayer and true prayer.  There are those whose fast is agreeable to Him and others who are reproved. There are false prayers and others which are a medicine of life.” 

In my first Pastoral Letter I reflected with you on the Mystery of the Eucharist.  My second Pastoral Letter was on the Mystery of Penance.  In this third Pastoral Letter, with hope that our prayer may indeed become more and more a “medicine of life”, I offer a humble reflection on the topic of prayer and liturgy:  Why do we pray, how do we pray, and what is liturgy? 

The Prayer of Jesus

Jesus was asked by his disciples, “Teach us to pray” (Lk 11:1). He said, “When you pray go to your room, close your door, and pray to your Father in private.” (Mt. 6:6) Jesus meant that going to God alone in prayer is crucial to deepening one’s relationship with Him. When He prayed alone, Jesus “spent the night in communion with God.” (Lk 6:12)  He would be found “praying in a certain place.” (Lk: 11:1)  He would go to the Mount of Olives “as was his custom.” (Lk 22:39)  Quiet time alone with God, whether in a quiet church before the Divine Liturgy, in silent adoration before the Blessed Sacrament or in the quiet of our home strengthens our communion with Him.  

Jesus also said “when two or three are gathered in my name, there I am in their midst.” (Mt. 18:20)  When Jesus prayed with others He followed a certain pattern of prayer. Since His youth, He went to the Temple with His parents “as was their custom.” (Lk 2:41)  He observed the Sabbath by going to the Synagogue “as he was in the habit of doing.” (Lk 4:16) He observed the Passover when He told Peter and John, “Go and prepare our Passover supper for us.” (Lk 2:8)Throughout Scripture we find that our Lord prayed both alone and with others; it is His will that we do the same. 

The Prayer of the Early Church 

An account of the prayer life of the first Christians can be found in the Acts of the Apostles: “They devoted themselves to the apostles’ instructions and the communal life, to the breaking of the bread and the prayers.” (Acts 2:42)  In the following chapter of Acts we also read:  “The community of believers was one heart and one mind, none of them claimed anything as his own; rather everything was held in common.”   Christian prayer was from the beginning a combination of prayer, sacrifice and doing what is right.  Prayer is not just a ritual act or something done in memory of Christ.  Prayer, sacrifice and morality, that is, an ethnical life based on Gospel principles, go hand in hand. 

When he met with the U.S. Catholic Bishops on April 16, 2008 in Washington, DC, Pope Benedict said:

“Is it consistent to profess our beliefs in church on Sunday, and then during the week to promote business practices or medical procedures contrary to those beliefs?  Is it consistent for practicing Catholics to ignore or exploit the poor and the marginalized, to promote sexual behavior contrary to Catholic moral teaching, or to adopt positions that contradict the right to life of every human being from conception to natural death?  Any tendency to treat religion as a private matter must be resisted.  Only when their faith permeates every aspect of their lives do Christians become truly open to the transforming power of the Gospel.”

 Whenever we pray, alone or with others, the demands of a loving God always have claim over us. The fourth century Syriac writer, Aphrahat, in his Demonstration on Prayer says:

“Purity of heart constitutes prayer more than do all the prayers that are uttered aloud, and silence to a mind that is sincere is better than the loud voice of someone crying out.” (IV)

When Prayer Becomes Liturgy 

Prayer becomes liturgy when it is the prayer of the Church in the power of the Holy Spirit. The Greek word leiturgiameans “work” of the people, yet in this context work has a special meaning. As found in the Book of Genesis, God worked six days; He saw that what He made was good, and rested on the seventh day. (Gen 2:2)  Thus, properly understood, liturgy is work as God works neither rushed, nor imposed, done consciously, willingly and deliberately, with reverence and respect. 

 The full meaning of Christian liturgy is not always appreciated in our modern world of fast food and instant self-gratification. Work is not something to finish quickly in order to enjoy leisure.  In a biblical sense, liturgy is, work and leisure together, since work properly understood is cooperation with God to build and create, and leisure is rest and renewal in God. 

For the first Christians, and still for us today, the Eucharist is celebrated on the “eighth day,” the day of Resurrection (Sunday), which was also the “first day of the week,” (Jn 20:1) recounting that on the first day of creation God made the heavens and earth. (Gen 1:3).  The liturgy of the early Christians was thus a continuation of God’s work of creation.

What is it then that we do when we celebrate liturgy?  Is liturgy drama?  Is it reading done in common?  Is liturgy remembering, or performing ritual? Is it speaking, listening, or silence? Are we spectators or participants in liturgy? Is liturgy personal prayer or communal prayer? Liturgy is drama and common reading, ritual and remembering, listening, speaking, and silence. It is personal and communal, prayer. We are never spectators but participants. Yet it is none of these unless it is first and foremost prayer, in the power of the Holy Spirit, leading us to do what is holy and good.

We can define prayer as conversation with a loving God. The purpose of prayer is to praise, adore, thank and petition God, and to deepen our union with Christ and the Church.  However, due to our imperfect human nature, prayer also means repentance and conversion. Thus the goal of all liturgy, like that of all prayer, is conversion.  The Greek word for conversion is metanoia, meaning, “turning towards God.” This includes contrition, openness to correction, listening to God, and being pruned by Him so that our relationship with Him can grow deeper and more fruitful, as the “branches from the vine.”  (John 15:2)  

A tenth century Syriac monk, Rabban Isho, who heard about the exquisite harmonies, elaborate processions and beautiful ritual of the Byzantine imperial court liturgy asked this simple and much revealing question, “but does it bring anyone to repentance?”  Liturgy can and should be beautiful, but unless it is also prayer, helping the worshipper to turn from sin towards God and to do what is good, it is not authentic.

Liturgy as Public Worship 

 Liturgy is public; all are welcome. The Church does not allow us to be rugged individualists.  Even the interior work of personal conversion and repentance has a communal component because we are and always will be members of one another. As Saint Paul says, we are “one body in Christ”, (1 Cor 12) and as St. John says, “one who has no love for the brother he has seen, cannot love the God he has not seen.” (1 John 4:20) 

The Fathers of the Second Vatican Council asked that our worship be “active, conscious and fruitful.”  The more we learn and appreciate liturgy, the more active and fruitful will be our prayer. Saint Jerome, the fourth century Scripture scholar, said, “Ignorance of the Scriptures is ignorance of Christ.”  Since liturgy is based on and springs from the Scriptures we can also add that ignorance of the Church’s liturgy is also ignorance of Christ for it is our way of meeting Christ and doing what He asked at the Last Supper when He said, “Do this in memory of me.” (Luke 22:19)  

Eucharist

The Church’s liturgical life takes its greatest inspiration from the Eucharist. 

“When the hour came, he took his place at table with the apostles… Then he took the bread, said the blessing, broke it, and gave it to them, saying, ‘this is my body, which will be given for you; do this in memory of me;’ and likewise the cup after they had eaten, saying, ‘This cup is the new covenant in my blood, which will be shed for you’.”  (Lk 22:14-20) 

The Eucharistic Liturgy is “the summit toward which the activity of the Church is directed; at the same time it is the font from which all her power flows.” (Second Vatican Council, Document on the Liturgy, no. 10).

In addition to recounting our Lord’s Last Supper, liturgy also includes the celebration of His “conception, birth, holy baptism, saving passion, life-giving death, burial for three days, glorious resurrection, ascension into heaven, sitting at the right hand of the Father, wondrous, awesome and royal return.” (Anaphora of St. Mark) and places their commemoration strategically throughout the year for one sole purpose: to praise God with the power of the Holy Spirit and to help the believer become more closely united to Christ. 

From the Maronite Evening Prayer for Wednesday of Holy Week, we pray:

O Christ,
On this day fill our hearts and spirits
with the memory of your passion.
We live it with you hour by hour
and we follow you from place to place.
We do this because in each place you left something
and each hour has given you its portion of the passion,
to the point of your death on the cross.
May we reap from them the inexhaustible fruits and teachings,
which will be a source of spiritual life flowing to eternal life.

Liturgy centers on the life of Christ. However, Old Testament events before the birth of Christ, such as the Passover, the Dedication of the Temple, the Forty Years in the Desert, and the Entering into the Promised Land, are celebrated as they pertain to the person and life of Christ.  Likewise, after Christ’s earthly life, liturgy commemorates events in the life of the Church, such as the Martyrdom of Stephen, the Finding of the True Cross, the Establishment of the Chair of Saint Peter in Antioch and Rome, and the feasts of Saints Peter and Paul, because the Church is a continuation of Christ’s presence in the world.

Also included in Christian liturgy are the Seven Mysteries (Sacraments): Baptism and Chrismation (Confirmation); Eucharist; Penance; Anointing of the Sick; Marriage; and Holy Orders.  Liturgy also includes the Divine Office, which consists of seven canonical hours such as morning, evening, and noon prayers, along with the other hours that the Church prays.  Other liturgical celebrations are the Christmas Novena, Fridays in Lent, Eucharistic Adoration, the liturgical seasons, feastdays of Mary and the saints, funerals, as well as commemorations of the local Church. Liturgy defines who we are as faithful followers of Christ and liturgy defines His Church.

The Church 

Liturgy is the “soul” of the Church. Each Particular Church has its own specific liturgy.   For example, Maronites celebrate their own liturgical tradition, as do the Coptic, Chaldean, Armenian, Latin, and Byzantine Churches.  Liturgy is what makes a Church fully “Herself,” and makes the Particular Church a gift to the Universal Church.  For this reason, we must respect and protect the integrity and inner intelligence of liturgy, and safeguard its power to transform.  We then pass this sacred work on to the next generation, so that through the liturgy Christ may continue to do in others what He has done in us. 

Christ Himself gave us the first Eucharistic liturgy at the Last Supper and once again at Emmaus, where “they came to know Him in the breaking of the bread.”  (Luke 24:35) Liturgy was then expanded and refined by inspired writers, poets, mystics, thinkers, bishops, priests and faithful who wrote and scripted this sacred work. Today the celebrant and faithful are the last in the Church’s historical line to have a hand in liturgy, and are thus bound to be faithful to the past and vigilant in the present, so as to pass this gift intact to the next generation. 

The Church uses everything at Her disposal to convey the meaning and power of the events of Christ and His Church. Liturgy incorporates chant, procession, ritual, use of material goods, such us water, oil, incense, bread, wine and icons, and takes place in appropriately prepared surroundings. Liturgy draws the worshipper more deeply into union with the risen Christ engaging all five of the senses - touch, smell, sight, hearing and taste.

In liturgy time stands still, events of the past become present again, and we appropriate their power and meaning for our lives today.  In the Maronite Evening Prayer for Fridays in Easter we pray: 

O Christ, may we understand the meaning of your resurrection
so that we may not see in it a purely historical event
or only a foundation of our faith,
but a life which we must realize in ourselves every day,
a hope which we must draw each moment from our faith, 
so that our souls may become just by your life,
and our hope may be united to your hope, 
and in your kingdom we shall glorify you face to face.
both here and there we shall praise you with a ceaseless love, forever.

The Paschal Mystery

The power and meaning of Christ’s Paschal Mystery, His passion, death, resurrection and ascension, give meaning to our own life, death, suffering and future hope.  In the Maronite Evening Prayer for Holy Week we pray:

O Christ, in recalling your passion we are saddened,
but its memory also fills us with joy.
For you and for us, it is both sorrowful and joyful; 
it kills and gives life;
it brings humiliation and glory.
For us it is necessary and there is nothing equal to it.
For you, it is both feared and desired.
Because of your passion may we feel the sadness, which brings repentance
and the joy, which does not forget you.
Thus, all sadness and joy will be for your glory,
now and forever.

 Through the writings of Saint Paul, we are reminded:  “For me life means Christ; hence dying is so much gain”; (Phil 1:21) “I have been crucified with Christ, and the life I live now is not my own; Christ is living in me;” (Gal 2:20) “Is not the cup of blessing we bless a sharing in the blood of Christ? Is not the bread we break, a sharing in the body of Christ?” (1 Cor 10: 16, 17)   

In Eucharistic liturgy we celebrate Christ’s death and resurrection as gift.  In return we give ourselves as gift and we receive Christ, crucified and raised from the dead, as gift under the veil of bread and wine. The Eucharistic celebrates the Paschal Mystery in a most fitting way, is the most meaningful of all liturgical celebrations because it leads us to deeper union with Christ in His Paschal Mystery and to communion with others in the Church.  As Pope Benedict XVI stated so eloquently in his Post Apostolic Exhortation entitled Eucharist, Sacrament of Charity:

In the sacrament of the Eucharist, Jesus shows us in particular 
the truth about the love, which is the very essence of God.  
It is this evangelical truth, which challenges each of us and our whole being.  
For this reason, the Church, which finds in the Eucharist the very center of 
her life, is constantly concerned to proclaim to all, 
opportune importune (cf. 2 Tim 4:2), that God is love.  
Precisely because Christ has become for us the food of truth, 
the Church turns to every man and woman, inviting them 
freely to accept God’s gift.

So often in our utilitarian society we use people and produce things for personal advantage.  Liturgy, on the other hand, as we see from the story in Acts of the Apostles, calls us to be “of one heart and one mind,” and enables us to see beyond a utilitarian mentality to a new way of living where no one is ‘used’ and no product produced, rather, a person is encountered, and that person is Christ Jesus, and as Saint Paul says, “Him crucified.” (1 Cor 2:2)  

The Crucified One invites us to follow Him, even at great cost to ourselves; yet we know that in Him our “souls will find rest,” for His “yoke is easy” and His “burden is light.” (Mt. 11:28-30) 

Liturgy and Language 

From the time of Jesus and the early disciples both Jewish and Christian liturgy incorporated different languages.  Jesus, in the synagogue liturgies, was used to a combination of classical Hebrew and Aramaic, the vernacular.  The disciples of Jesus - Peter, the Apostles and Paul - also prayed in the vernacular, whether that was Greek, Latin or Aramaic, yet they also used the Psalms and the other Old Testament passages in classical Hebrew.  Likewise, they included Greek expressions such as Kyrios (Phil 2) which means “Lord”, and Maranatha an Aramaic expression which means “come Lord” (Rev 22:20).

Language was a bridge to others.  Today, with the experience of the Maronite Church here in the United States, the same is true.  English is the vernacular and so our prayer and liturgy should be mostly in English.  However, we must also keep in mind that classical Syriac is our ancient heritage, so we must be familiar with some prayers in Syriac for example:  the Qadishat, the entrance dialogue at the altar, the Words of Institution and the Invocation of the Holy Spirit.

Moreover, because many people are used to Arabic we must also accommodate their desire to pray in their own vernacular.  The appropriate balance is a pastoral decision that must be made by the priest after considering the needs of the people. When we balance the languages of the liturgy, however, we must keep in mind not to exclude anyone, for not everyone is bi-lingual in Arabic and English. Therefore, those who know little or no Arabic must feel included, as well as those who knows no English.  All worshippers must be willing to accommodate a blend of English, Arabic and Syriac.

What Middle Eastern Christian family would invite to their table someone that they would not feed? The same is true of liturgical music and prayer. Language in liturgy must be a bridge, never a barrier.

Mary

The early Church, and the Church of today has remembered that when entrusting His mother to the care of John at the Cross, Jesus gave her to each of us as well. Can you imagine Mary and the Apostle John at Ephesus, when they gathered for the “breaking of the bread”? Mary, who bore the Son of God, clothed Him with her own flesh and blood, and lovingly raised Him with Joseph, received in Holy Communion the One whose body was once part of hers!  How can one fathom this?  

Prayer is Marian. She received the Word, made Him part of her life, and gave Him to others as a gift. She inspires us to do the same. Her life is prayer: “May it be done to me according to your word” (Lk 1:38) she said, even before our Lord at Gethsemane.  

At the Transfer of Gifts (Offertory) we pray: “Mary’s womb received Me like good earth a grain of wheat, behold the priest bears Me aloft to the altar.” We then pray, “With these offerings placed before us let us remember all who pleased the Lord from Adam to the present, especially the Blessed Virgin Mary, Mother of God, and all the saints.” Liturgy is an exchange of gifts; we offer ourselves as did Mary, and God offers His divine life to us in exchange.  

Divinity and Humanity in Liturgy

The more devoutly we enter into the divine work of liturgy, the more human we become. Saint Peter said that we are “sharers in the divine nature” (2 Peter 1:4). In the Maronite Divine Liturgy the work of God and the response of man are described thus:

 “You have united O Lord, Your divinity with our humanity, and our humanity with Your divinity; Your life with our mortality, and our mortality with Your life. You have assumed what is ours, and have given us what is Yours, for the life and salvation of our souls. To You be glory forever.” 

Liturgy should recreate in us the desire to be holy as God is holy, to live in daily communion with Him. We are on the receiving end of His generosity; liturgy is participation in His gift and our frail and yet lofty attempt to enter into the Divine life of the Father, Son and Holy Spirit. The Holy Spirit and a willing heart are essential. 

Liturgy and the Life of the Trinity

Saint John of Damascus, when responding to critics who mistakenly denounced Christians because they worship “three gods,” asked them what good is worshipping the One God who without a Word cannot speak to us, and without a Spirit cannot touch us? Liturgy helps us live in communion with this Triune God who speaks to us through His Word and touches us by His Spirit. 

The work of the Spirit enables us to truly meet Christ in liturgy. Liturgy is our way to “do this in memory” of Him, (1Cor 11:24) is meant to make us pleasing to Him, “a living sacrifice, holy and acceptable to God, a spiritual worship” (Rom 12:1).

On April 19, 2008 Pope Benedict told 20,000 youth gathered in New York:           

“What matters most is that you develop your personal relationship with God.   That relationship is expressed in prayer….Friends, do not be afraid of

silence or stillness, listen to God, adore Him in the Eucharist.  Let His word

shape your journey as an unfolding of holiness... Through the liturgy, the ‘work of Jesus’ is continually brought into contact with history, with our lives in order to shape them… Whenever you gather for Mass, when you go to Confession, whenever you celebrate any of the Sacraments, Jesus is at work.”

When we enter the sacred work we call liturgy and begin “Glory be to the Father, and to the Son and to the Holy Spirit,” we enter into God’s time and can never return the same. 

Conclusion

How does a Christian pray?  Prayer is a personal and communal conversation with God. We pray alone and with others, just as Jesus did.  Prayer also has an important ethical and communal component if it is to be acceptable to God. Praying alone, enables us to more readily and effectively pray with others. In prayer, we address God as “Our Father”, and we become brothers and sisters to one another.

Why do Christians pray?  We pray in order to enter into the life of the Triune God - Father, Son, and Holy Spirit - with the desire and hope to be one with Christ and to live true communion with Him and others.  When we pray with true humility, we find ourselves naturally with some fear and trembling, for in prayer we come face to face with the Living God whose great love for us obliges us to turn from sin to become more like Him. 

What is liturgy? Liturgy is the prayer of the Church, the very soul of the Church; it is unique to Her, and animates all Her charitable and spiritual activity. Liturgy is public and communal even if done alone, as in the Divine Office.  Liturgy is the gift of the Spirit to the Church and connects the praying Church to the Sacred Scriptures, the Apostles and to Jesus Christ Himself.  Language serves as a bridge, and together, the people of God respond to Him with love saying:

Holy are You O God, Holy are You O Strong One, holy are You O Immortal One,

 O Jesus Christ, Son of the living God, have mercy on us; Lord teach us to pray! 

Bishop Gregory J. Mansour                                  Feast of the Holy Cross 2008